FIREWIRE:
So the Blender Says to the Toaster,
He Says...
September 23, 1998
Digital TV is going to put fire
in the walls. It is going to string fire from television set
to PC, and from PC to stereo. The digital revolution will run
fire through the walls from the living room, to the home office,
to the bedroom; all courtesy of IEEE 1394, or firewire, or firelink,
or Ilink--depending on who is asked.
IEEE 1394 is the new standard for high-speed digital data transmission
between electronic components, according Greg Gudorf, vice president
of marketing for digital media products at Sony. It is a connection
cable with the capacity to connect up to 63 devices in the home
and make the television the center of the universe, if it is
not already.
Firewire is the component of HDTV that Federal Communications
Commission Chairman William Kennard called a milestone
for the deployment of digital television.
The goal of firewire is to create a home network with digital
appliances using the IEEE 1394 standard to share information
in digital bits. Someday, the blender may be talking to the television.
Firewire sounds like an Orwellian concept, born of a post-apocalyptic
B-movie where machines somehow become humanized. But it is already
in use today, and many have barely noticed. Every time a digital
camcorder or digital camera is hooked up to a PC to download
movies or still frame photos to the family website, firewire
is in use. As the pictures are downloaded, these seemingly incompatible
machines share information about the familys most treasured
memories in the digital language of ones and zeroes.
But the current work on applying the IEEE 1394 standard to multiple
types of electronics equipment is creating a controversy between
the Consumer Electronics Manufacturers Association (CEMA) and
the National Cable Television Association (NCTA).
The FCC would like to see firewire used by the cable industry
and consumer electronics manufacturers to solve compatibility
problems between cable set-top boxes and the new digital TVs
slated to hit the market this fall. Chairman Kennard told the
NCTA and CEMA he would like to see this done by Nov. 1.
Both associations agree this is a great idea, but between these
thoughts and action, something has gone awry, according to letters
each group sent to the FCC recently. With the cooperation
of CEMA, NCTA President Decker Anstrom said, there
should be no problem completing a baseline 1394 specification
by Nov. 1, 1998. CEMA President Gary Shapiro agrees, saying
We are working aggressively to complete a 1394 interface
standard by Nov. 1, 1998.
However, the two groups do not appear to be working together.
Anstrom complains that manufacturers chose not to include inputs
for either IEEE 1394 or Quadrature Amplitude Modulation (QAM),
a specific digital transmission language, in the first generation
of digital TV setssome of which are already on the market.
The QAM standard was set by CableLabs, a cable industry funded
research group, in 1994 and is used by most cable set-top boxes.
But Shapiro argues CableLabs opted for the QAM standard without
CEMAs cooperation. Shapiro told the FCC he fears a CableLabs
standard may be overly complex and unnecessarily costly.
CEMA proposed its own solution to the firewire standard, which
Shapiro says the NCTA never responded to. The NCTA had no comment
on Shapiros charge.
So while these two organizations stand at opposite ends of the
schoolyard thumbing noses, consumers could be left in November
with $7,000 HDTV sets that may not be able to display digital
programming received from cable systems. The blender and the
television will stand silent, yearning to articulate.
David Connell |
|
OTHER DIGITAL
TV BEATS |
HBO
HDTV GETS READY:
Titles Coming Up On HBO HDTV
March 10, 1999 |
|
THE
DATA HORIZON:
PBS Tackles the Bandwidth Usage Question
February 24, 1999 |
|
RESEARCH:
The Reports Are in, But the Conclusions Are Confusing
February 10, 1999 |
|
|
NEW
FEES: There Is No Such Thing as Free Spectrum
January 27, 1999 |
|
|
CES
TV TALK: More Buzz than the Sequins on an Elvis Jacket
January 13, 1999 |
|
|
CES:
Bright Lights, Big Pictures to Hit Vegas
December 16, 1998 |
|
|
LOCAL
EFFORTS:
Broadcasters Give Viewers A Push Toward TV Purchase
November 18, 1998 |
|
|
FIRSTS:
Digital TV Broadcasts Hit the Airwaves
November 4, 1998 |
|
|
THOMSON'S
DBS BRAIN:
Channels ARE Plentiful
in New Digital TV
World
October 21, 1998 |
|
|
DECISIONS,
DECISIONS:
Taking the Plunge into Digital TV
October 7, 1998 |
|
|
THEY'RE HERE...
September 9, 1998 |
|
|